fix uk logo
uk fix banner

UK Benefits Deep Dive

Broken Britain: A Blueprint to Fix Our Welfare System

The creation of the welfare state was a defining moment of national solidarity; a promise that as a society, we would not leave the vulnerable behind. This system, built on the principles of community, partnership, and compassion, has been a force for good for generations. It represents the best of British values.

But that legacy is now at risk. A system designed to protect is now buckling under the weight of its own inefficiency and unsustainable costs. As Henry Hill wrote for Unherd, the hard truth is that "the UK is living wildly beyond its means." To protect the principle of a strong safety net for the future, we must be honest about the present. The current system is failing taxpayers and, crucially, failing those who need it most. This blueprint is not about dismantling a cherished institution; it's about rebuilding it to be fit for the challenges of the 21st century.

Our benefits system is failing. It’s failing taxpayers with spiralling costs, and it’s failing those it’s meant to help, trapping them in dependency instead of offering a path to work.

Since the Covid pandemic, a staggering 2.8 million people have become inactive due to long-term sickness—a tragic waste of human potential and a cost we can no longer afford.

The National Audit Office has laid bare the truth: tinkering around the edges is not an option. The time for fundamental, root-and-branch reform is now.

This is a blueprint for a benefits system that is fair, efficient, and fiscally sustainable. A plan that makes work pay, declares war on waste, and could put our country back on the path to sound finances.

Number of People Inactive Due to Long-Term Sickness
2.8 Million
Source: Post-Pandemic Data

From Safety Net to Springboard: A New Deal for Work

The first priority must be to unlock the potential of the millions left behind. This plan proposes transforming the welfare system from a passive safety net into an active springboard back into work.

  • Fixing Universal Credit: The five-week wait for a first payment pushes people into debt. It must end. Flexible payment cycles should also be introduced to match the reality of modern work.
  • Investing in People, Not Dependency: Investment in getting people back on their feet should be accelerated, bringing forward £300 million to boost total funding for employment, health, and skills support to £2.2 Billion over the next four years.

Fixing the Finances: A Double Dividend

Getting people into work delivers a powerful two-part benefit for the public finances. Firstly, it directly shrinks the colossal £288 Billion annual welfare bill.

Secondly, it boosts the economy and increases tax revenues. Every individual who moves from benefits to employment turns from a net cost to the state into a net contributor. The proposed £2.2 Billion investment in skills and support is not just spending; it's an investment in growth, designed to yield a multi-Billion-pound return by helping even a fraction of the 2.8 million people currently inactive due to sickness find work and contribute to a stronger economy.

Proposed Investment vs. Total Annual Welfare Bill
£288 Billion
£2.2B
Total Bill
Investment

Dignity and Sustainability: A Modern Disability Benefit System

Spending on health and disability benefits is on an unsustainable trajectory, set to hit £63 Billion by 2028-29. Claims for Personal Independence Payment (PIP) have doubled since the pandemic. The system is broken, causing anxiety for the disabled and failing to control costs.

  • A Single, Humane Assessment: The discredited and "fatally flawed" Work Capability Assessment should be scrapped. In its place, a single, simplified assessment must focus on the real-world impact of a disability, not just on a tick-box exercise.
  • A 'Right to Try' Guarantee: A new, legally-binding "Right to Try Guarantee" should be created, giving people the confidence to take a job without the fear of losing their financial support if it doesn’t work out.
  • Rebalancing for the Future: To ensure sustainability, this plan proposes reducing the Universal Credit health top-up for new claims from April 2026. Crucially, all existing claimants and those with the most severe, lifelong conditions would be fully protected under this proposal.

Fixing the Finances: Bending the Cost Curve

This reform is about controlling the unsustainable growth in future spending. By rebalancing payments for new claims and providing a 'Right to Try' guarantee, the system removes the financial penalty for attempting to work. This puts spending on a more sustainable path, helping to avert the forecast rise to £63 Billion a year. The goal is to "bend the curve" of future spending downwards, delivering Billions in savings over the long term compared to the current trajectory. This responsible approach manages future liabilities and ensures the disability budget remains focused on those who need it most, directly helping to control the national debt.

Projected Rise in Health & Disability Spending
Current
£63 Billion
By 2028-29

Ending the Housing Benefit Trap

Britain is set to spend £35.3 Billion on housing benefits next year—a vast sum that simply subsidises sky-high private rents without fixing the underlying housing crisis. The freeze on Local Housing Allowance (LHA) has made it impossible for low-income families to find a home, pushing them towards homelessness.

  • Immediate Relief: As a first step, LHA rates must be unfrozen and relinked to cover at least the cheapest 30% of local market rents. This would provide an immediate lifeline to families struggling to keep a roof over their heads.
  • Shift from Subsidy to Supply: The long-term plan should be to stop pouring Billions into the pockets of private landlords and instead invest in building a new generation of high-quality, affordable social housing.

Fixing the Finances: From Dead Money to Public Assets

This is a two-stage plan for fiscal sanity. In the short term, relinking LHA provides stability, preventing the higher costs of emergency housing and helping people keep jobs, thereby boosting tax revenues. The long-term strategy provides a structural fix to the national debt. Instead of the £35.3 Billion housing benefit bill disappearing as "dead money" into the private rental market each year, investing in social housing creates valuable public assets. These assets will drastically reduce the housing benefit bill year after year, generating permanent, structural savings that will directly help to pay down the national debt for generations to come.

Zero Tolerance: Targeting Waste and Fraud

Tough choices must be made to ensure every penny of taxpayers' money is spent wisely. The current level of mismanagement is a national disgrace.

  • A High-Tech War on Fraud: For 36 consecutive years, the DWP’s accounts have failed their audit. Benefit overpayments have hit a record £9.7 Billion a year—£7.3 Billion of which is outright fraud. This is unacceptable.

The UK must invest in a state-of-the-art, AI-powered task-force to stop fraudsters in their tracks and save Billions.

  • Focusing on Core Support: To put the system on a sustainable footing, this plan proposes stopping payments for Attendance Allowance and Carer's Allowance. Removing these benefits, which cost over £8 Billion a year, would allow resources to be focused on core support and direct the savings to paying down the UK National Debt.
Annual Benefit Overpayments: £9.7 Billion
Fraud
£7.3B
Error
£2.4B

Fixing the Finances: A £17 Billion Attack on Inefficiency

This two-pronged approach provides the most direct and substantial savings. It targets over £17.7 Billion in annual spending: the £9.7 Billion lost to fraud and error, plus the £8 Billion+ spent on non-core allowances.

Every Billion pounds reclaimed from fraudsters or saved from non-essential payments is a Billion pounds that does not need to be borrowed. This directly reduces the budget deficit and makes an immediate, significant contribution to paying off our national debt.

A Simpler, Fairer System for Families

The benefits system should be a helping hand for families, not a bureaucratic nightmare.

  • Scrapping the Unfair Child Benefit Tax: The complex and unfair High Income Child Benefit Charge should be abolished. It absurdly penalises single-earner households more than those with two earners on a much higher combined income. It should be replaced with a simple, higher threshold of £120,000.

Fixing the Finances: The Efficiency Dividend

While not the largest saving, this reform creates a valuable "efficiency dividend". A simpler, fairer system is cheaper to run. Abolishing the complex charge would remove hundreds of thousands of families from the costly self-assessment tax system, saving significant administrative costs for HMRC. This stops the government wasting taxpayers' money administering a flawed and unfair policy. It is a common-sense measure that contributes to the overall goal of a leaner, more efficient state and ensures the system works for, not against, hard working families.

A New Consensus for Britain

Fixing our welfare system is not a choice between compassion and cost-cutting; it is about achieving both. The path to a solvent and fair Britain requires a new consensus: one that combines fiscal discipline with strategic investment in people. This blueprint strikes that balance. It is a plan not only to fix our national debt but to restore the promise of the welfare state—a system that offers a hand up, not just a handout, and builds a stronger, more prosperous nation for everyone.

Targeted Annual Savings

£17.7B+ Total

A breakdown of our projected annual savings.

£9.7B

Reclaimed from Fraud & Error

£8B+

Saved from Non-Core Allowances